In
today’s workplace communications takes many forms. As a member of project
manager team both written and verbal communication is important when sharing information
with the team. Informal and formal communications are also meaningful ways to
share information. Effective communication
is “sharing the right messages with the right people in a timely manner” Portny
et al (2008). The ability to communicate well, both orally and in writing is a
critical skill for project managers. Non-verbal signs like attitude, body
language and timing also contribute to effective communication.
A Comparison of three Modes of Communication
Email
|
Voicemail
|
Face-to-Face
| |
Interpretation
|
Email
communication is the most impersonal form of communication. The message in the words is clear and
concise and conveys the urgency of the request. This medium is considered
written communication.
|
Voicemail
is more personal. The sender did not identify herself, but the voice
conveying the message is clear with a professional tone. The voice also conveys authority and urgency.
This medium is considered oral communication that is formal because the
message is recorded.
|
This
is the most personal form of communication because the sender is in close
proximity to the receiver. This is
definitely informal oral communication. The sender of the message seems
apologetic about the request. The sender is making every attempt to not seem annoyed.
|
Strengths
|
The
tone of the message is clear and concise and explains the reason for the
request and the consequence if the request is not granted. The message does
not relay the mood of the sender. This method is straight forward and to the
point but lacks a personal touch.
|
A
voicemail allows the sender to be clear and concise but distant and more
formal. Unlike the email the receiver can judge the tone and mood of the
sender’s voice. This method is also straight forward and to the point.
|
This
method allows interaction between the sender and the receiver. The receiver can
make a judgment about the sender’s mood, tone, body language and facial expression
in relation to the message, and make a judgment about the urgency of the
request. This is informal communication as there is no written record of this
request
|
Weaknesses
|
If
the message is poorly written the words can be misunderstood causing hurt
feelings or anger.
There
is also no guarantee that the message will be received as the receiver will
have to open the email and read the content.
|
There
can also be misinterpretations of the message and there is also no guarantee
that the message will be received as the receiver will have to access the
voicemail machine and listen to the content.
|
There
is no written record of this message and the receiver can forget that the
message was ever sent.
|
Suggestions
|
Face
to face communication is ideal but it is also necessary to have a written record
of the message to ensure that there is no confusion about the content of the message.
No one method is satisfactory. A voicemail message should always be followed by
either an email or a face to face meeting. A face to face meeting by an email
or some form of written record to ensure that the message is not only sent
but received.
|
References:
"The Art of Effective Communication". Multimedia Program. Laureate
Education, Inc.
Portny, S. E.,
Mantel, S. J., Meredith, J. R., Shafer, S. M., Sutton, M. M., & Kramer, B.
E. (2008). Project management: Planning, scheduling, and controlling
projects. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Chapter
12, "Communicating and Documenting Project Progress".
Stolovitch, H. (n/d). "Communicating with Stakeholders".
Multimedia. Laureate Education, Inc.
Hi Pat,
ReplyDeleteI’d like to compliment your blog this week. The use of a table was a smart way to organize the information – and visually appealing. I agree with you that face-to-face communication is the most personal and may be ideal to getting the message across, but an email provides a paper trail of events. We don’t know any background of Mark and Jane’s working relationship, but I thought her body language and facial expressions gave off some negative vibes. You mentioned that she seemed almost apologetic. I just rewatched the video after reading your post. I still don’t know! However it is interpreted, it is the most direct and immediate of the delivery methods. If Jane takes this direct approach, as you mention she can create a paper trail by following up with an email.
In Communicating with Stakeholders, Dr. Stolovitch mentioned that he keeps a daily journal when working on a project. I thought that was good advice. As a teacher, I tend to get caught up with the busyness of the day, and I’m not always so diligent at keeping journal entries or anecdotal records.
Reference
Laureate Education, (n.d.). Communicating with stakeholders. Retrieved from
https://class.waldenu.edu/webapps/portal/frameset.jsp?tab_tab_group_id=_2_1&url=%2Fwebapps%2Fblackboard%2Fexecute%2Flauncher%3Ftype%3DCourse%26id%3D_4065699_1%26url%3D
Pat, I really like the chart! That is an effective way to discuss the three modes of communication. I agree that there should be some form of written communication, too. I often use e-mails as reminders. Even if I have read them, I can mark them as "unread" and then every time I check my e-mail I have a "reminder." Great ideas and great breakdown of the three means of communication!
ReplyDeleteCheers,
Lesley
Pat,
ReplyDeleteGreat breakdown analogy of the email, voice-mail & face-to-face between Jane & Mark. Seeing is believing I say. It's hard sometime interpreting an emails tone & urgency unless noted. A voice-mail can have tone / attitude, but sometimes it's just not convincing enough. Having Mark call Jane as soon as he listened to her voice-mail would have been better. As for the face-to-face, I think Jane was convincing & was able to get her point across to Mark to get her the data asap.
Cheyl